| N/A | Cobbetts Ln
, Shelter Island, ny | N/A | View Details |
| N/A | Country Club Dr
, Shelter Island, ny | N/A | View Details |
| N/A | Dinah Rock Rd
, Shelter Island, ny | N/A | View Details |
| N/A | E Thomas St
, Shelter Island, ny | N/A | View Details |
| $675,000 | Hay Beach Rd
, Shelter Island, ny | $675,000 | View Details |
| N/A | Locust Woods Dr
, Shelter Island, ny | N/A | View Details |
| N/A | N Cartwright Rd
, Shelter Island, ny | N/A | View Details |
| N/A | N Ferry Rd
, Shelter Island, ny | N/A | View Details |
| $609,000 | N Menantic Rd
, Shelter Island, ny | $609,000 | View Details |
| $826,667 | Quail Hedge Ln
, Shelter Island, ny | $826,667 | View Details |
| $1,300,000 | Quaker Path
, Shelter Island, ny | $1,300,000 | View Details |
| N/A | Ram Island Dr
, Shelter Island, ny | N/A | View Details |
| N/A | Ram Island Rd
, Shelter Island, ny | N/A | View Details |
| N/A | Southwick Ln
, Shelter Island, ny | N/A | View Details |
| $687,500 | Spring Garden Ave
, Shelter Island, ny | $687,500 | View Details |
| N/A | St Mary's Rd
, Shelter Island, ny | N/A | View Details |
| $725,000 | W Neck Rd
, Shelter Island, ny | $725,000 | View Details |
| $52,500 | Wade Rd
, Shelter Island, ny | $52,500 | View Details |
| $860,000 | Wesley Ave
, Shelter Island, ny | $860,000 | View Details |
| $980,000 | Wheeler Road
, Shelter Island, ny | $980,000 | View Details |
| N/A | Woodbine Way
, Shelter Island, ny | N/A | View Details |
